TRG blog: Who’s a Scalper?
comments powered by Disqus

TRG Blog: Analysis from TRG Arts


Who’s a scalper?

Rick Lester | June 25, 2012 5:36 AM
Sign from the Vancouver Folk Music Festival.
Photo: Richard Eriksson
The secondary ticket market is a hot button issue across the performing arts and broader ticketed-event universe. Anything this huge has to be.

The New York Times recently estimated that ticket sales through brokers and other resellers “is a $4.5 billion business nationwide.” Revenue of this magnitude in a sector with few barriers to entry likely means that further growth is inevitable.

After attending a long series of arts conferences this year where experts from the field have talked insistently about the evils of the secondary ticketing market, one has to wonder: Do ticket brokers have mothers? Surely, only a mother could love these people. The list of pejoratives is lengthy. “Scalper” is one of the kinder terms. Thus my question: Who’s a scalper?

For some, the answer is simple. Brokers are bad and the only solution is to legislate them out of existence.

Yes, some operators engage in shady business practices. For me, those who sell online using sites designed to deceive the customer should be dealt with by the justice system. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) prohibits unfair or deceptive business practices. Fraudulently pretending to be a primary ticketing outlet certainly exceeds my ethical threshold even if it escapes the long arm of the law.

For the moment, let’s set aside the issues of how fraudulent dealers get away with their practices. We’re in an era in which a newly “illegal” server can become instantly legal by relocating to another state or country with just a few keystrokes.

Instead, consider this: For every transaction completed by broker, there is a patron – a fan! – who is making a purchase. The only reason the secondary market exists is because someone needs a seat for that “can’t miss” event or performance.

Fan or Scalper?

Now consider the short list below and ask yourself: Who is the legitimate fan and who is the scalper?
  • I'm a subscriber who can't attend the next performance in my series and a friend offers to buy them from me.
  • I'm a season ticket holder who buys extra seats that I knowingly won't "need". My intent is take a friend, or more likely to sell my extra seats. The sale pays for my “real” season ticket. (This is a common practice among fans for many amateur and professional sports teams.)
  • I'm a ticket seller who occasionally helps my friends get tickets outside of the normal channels.
  • I’m a hotel concierge who helps guests obtain tickets to sold-out events. I earn bigger tips in exchange for finding a way to get better seats or earlier access than presenters typically allow.
  • I'm an artist, promoter, or presenter who makes tickets available to fan club members. These transactions may not even be available through the house ticketing system. I may also allocate tickets to a broker, who pays me full price plus a percentage of any price above "retail".
  • I’m a small business operator. I’m a ticket speculator. I take huge risks by subscribing, becoming a donor, a "group" organizer or member of your organization for the sole purpose of obtaining ticket inventory that I intend to resell at a price greater than face value. Using a variety of techniques, I may buy thousands of tickets each month or year.
  • I’m a software developer whose application can force its way into a ticketing system to simultaneously buy blocks of prime inventory while blocking others from accessing the system.
For me, the conversation demonizing resellers exists on a slippery slope. Some situations appear ethically clear-cut while others obviously less so. However, they all share common factor: A willing buyer. And like all of the world’s oldest professions, the seller only exists to satisfy the perceived need of a buyer.

Legislation has never been much of a deterrent when a willing buyer seeks a willing seller. That’s why some professions have lasted for a very long time.

This is just the beginning of our view in this debate. Comments?






print



Related Articles
Are Scalpers Winning the Gold at the London Olympics?
Seat-o-nomics


Be notified of future content like this with eNews.

Sign up for TRG's eNews and you'll be notified when more content like this is posted, as well as getting our latest research, blog posts, and webinar announcements delivered straight to your inbox. Simply fill out the form below:

* indicates required

 

Case Study: Lyric Theatre of Oklahoma

Annual operating budget up 32% in 5 seasons

Lyric Theatre of Oklahoma 
 Photo: Joseph Mills

After a poor year for earned revenue in 2012, Lyric Theatre of Oklahoma (LTO) had rebounded and was experiencing a growth spurt. In 2013, Director of Marketing Danyel Siler had turned her attention to single tickets.

Her hard work had paid off, but season tickets were still a challenge. “Season tickets were steadily declining,” she said. “The season ticket campaign had been done the same way for years, maybe even decades. And we blamed the fall on the trend that subs were declining everywhere. Our executive director, artistic director, and I all knew something needed to change, but we didn’t know what.”

Read More>>


Killer Group Sales Campaigns

A boot camp for arts marketing and fundraising leaders


Friday, August 18, 2017 
Online Workshop (11am-2pm MDT)

Do group sales contribute less than 10% of your single ticket revenues? Does your organization only sell tickets to groups reactively? Are you setting group sales goals only to fall short every year?

After subscriptions, group sales is the most important ticket-buying group for an arts and culture organization to cultivate. In this one-day session, learn how to leverage your group sales program to create a renewal base of loyal customers, while also driving new patrons to attend, all by tapping into the social networks that already exist within your marketplace. 

You’ll leave with your own, unique group sales campaign plan for next season, front-line sales strategies, and projections of what is possible for growth.

Contributors


Jill Robinson
Adam Scurto
Amelia Northrup-
Simpson
J.L.Nave Vincent VanVleet Keri Mesropov
 

Upcoming Events

Professional Development Workshops

 

Killer Group Sales Campaigns - August 18, 2017; Online


Executive Summit in UK and Europe - September 28-29, 2017; Dublin, Ireland


Executive Summit in North America - October 12-13, 2017; Colorado Springs, CO

LEARN MORE

 

Conferences

Opera Europa Autumn Conference - October 1, 2017

American Museum Membership Conference - November 6-9, 2017; Seattle, WA

Americans for the Arts - National Arts Marketing Project (NAMP) - November 10-13, 2017; Memphis, TN

MEET UP WITH US



Admin Login